Why I bought Chaman Lal Setia Exports in 2014 and why it multiplied 40 times in less than 4 years?
Should you buy Blue Chips or Small Cap Stocks?
August 15, 2016
Why I bought Mold-Tek Packaging and why it Multiplied 46 Times in 7 years?
August 19, 2016
Chaman Lal Setia Exports Ltd
In 2014 I bought Chaman Lal Setia Exports heavily at a split-and-bonus-adjusted ₹5.5. It was a small, family-run rice exporter — exactly the kind of “boring” company the market loves to overlook. Today it trades near ₹278, a return of about 50 times. Here is why a humble bag of basmati rice became one of my most rewarding investments.
A global brand hiding in a commodity
On the surface Chaman Lal Setia sells rice — a commodity. But look closer and it is a branded basmati exporter shipping to more than 90 countries under names like Mithas, Maharani and Begum, and it carries the government’s ‘Star Export House’ status. Branding turns a commodity into a franchise: it earns better margins, builds repeat customers, and compounds quietly while investors dismiss it as “just a rice company.”
The fundamental strengths that made me buy
- A committed promoter. Promoters hold ~74% — a family with almost everything riding on the business getting it right.
- A conservative balance sheet. Very low debt (~₹83 crore against a market value many times larger), so the business funds its own growth.
- Strong returns for its industry. Return on capital of ~18% and return on equity of ~15% — excellent for a rice miller, and proof the brand premium is real.
- A wide export franchise. 300+ brands shipped to 90+ countries, earning valuable foreign exchange and diversifying away from any single market.
- An undemanding valuation. Even after the run, it has traded around ~13× earnings — rare value for a consistent, dividend-paying compounder.
Why the market kept underestimating it
For years the market priced Chaman Lal as a low-margin commodity trader. But as its branded, higher-margin exports grew and its returns stayed strong, investors were gradually forced to re-rate it from “rice trader” to “consistent consumer-export compounder.” When a genuinely good business is priced like a bad one, patience does the rest — in this case, roughly 50-fold worth of it.
Don’t take my word for it — it’s on the public record
My original buy call on Chaman Lal Setia is documented on my public Facebook profile, made when it was a ₹5.5 stock almost nobody was discussing. I bought it heavily precisely because the gap between its quality and its price was so wide.
“A brand turns a commodity into a franchise — and the market almost always pays up for that franchise, eventually.”
The lesson for you
Chaman Lal Setia is why I read past the industry label. “Just a rice company” hid a branded, cash-generative, globally diversified exporter trading at a commodity valuation. The label scares away lazy money — which is exactly why the patient investor gets to buy quality cheap.
Want to catch stocks like these before they move?
Explore how you can work with me — the same value-investing framework that found these winners, now applied for you.
Disclaimer: This article is a personal account of my own past investment decision, shared for educational purposes only. It is not a recommendation to buy or sell this or any stock at current prices. All return figures are calculated to recent market prices and adjusted for stock splits and bonuses; past performance is not a guarantee of future returns. Equity investments are subject to market risks. Please do your own research or consult your financial adviser before investing.
